The building was constructed in 1853 as the Cape Island Presbyterian Church. It later housed an Episcopal congregation and during the second half of the twentieth century the city of Cape May used the building as a community and visitor’s center. In 1994 the Cape May Stage began using the space to hold theatrical performances. The building exemplifies local carpenter-designed architecture and has good integrity. It includes Greek Revival-style elements as well as a unique belvedere. The building is a locally known landmark in the center of town. The recently restored exterior and the rehabilitated entrance vestibule are in excellent condition.

The grant helped fund restoration of the interior ceiling, walls, and floor.  The theater hosts numerous theatrical productions and educational activities throughout the year.